Now that a lot of the commotion has subsided I’m just curious to know how y’all are finding the Lemmy experience in general and whether you use it regularly like you did reddit?
It’s quite good as long as a thread is not political. As soon as anything even remotely political starts being discussed, it devolves into an absolute shitshow, political opinions on Lemmy seem to be much more extreme than on Reddit for some reason.
I use it daily and don’t go on reddit anymore. I’m missing a lot of things I used to look at but I don’t have anything to post on those topics.
Compared to reddit the quality of discussion is far better. It still feels like you can’t go against the grain without being banned. I haven’t had a spicy enough take on anything to test that yet but I’ve seen people getting instantly labeled as trolls and banned.
Overall it’s a good experience, I think the web ui is better than reddit without RES and I’m liking Jebora even if it’s buggy as hell.
In general, it’s been pretty good. Stuff is a bit unstable every now and then, but most of that changed when I switched away from lemmy.world.
There’s a couple of things to contend with though. There’s less content than there was on Reddit. This ultimately doesn’t matter that much for general browsing, as there is still plenty. But for more niche communities it now means barely any content. Even with larger topics like Formula 1 it’s quite noticeable that there’s a lot less people in there. It’s great during big discussions, but any smaller links or discussions often only have like 1 or 2 responses. For other communities it’s even worse. Some of the genres I listen to have basically nothing going on, while on Reddit the community was at least large enough to have a few nice discussions every moe and then. The same with many games that I really liked.
Another problem is federation with more (politically) extreme instances like lemmygrad, hexbear, and some right wing crap that was luckily defederated before I could remember their names. On the one hand, I don’t want defederation based on political opinion alone to be the norm. But neither do I particularly like getting constantly called a “lib” (even though I’m quite left wing compared to the national average) or get to read constant discussions on these topics wherever I go. I come here to read about fun stuff, unwind a bit, not to constantly read about people defending dictatorships. Hexbear is especially interesting, since their users also add a lot of fun memes and good content. But then equally they brigade comment sections and overwhelm anyone who disagrees with them.
Ending on a positive note: the software (apps, backend, frontend, etc) have really gotten a lot better over the past months. I’m using Connect at the moment and I really enjoy it. Bugs keep disappearing, to the point where I now have very few complaints. Apps is why I left Reddit, so seeing that we’re now (imo) in a better place than Reddit is a good thing.
On the one hand, I don’t want defederation based on political opinion alone to be the norm. But . . .
I come here to read about fun stuff, unwind a bit, not to constantly read about people defending dictatorships.
Just thought it was worth highlighting. Obviously, the view of Hexbear is that the people you are here calling autocratic aren’t autocratic, but that gets into discussion of political opinions and my point is that this is a political opinion.
My main problem with hexbear people (or at least the annoying ones) is that imo they’re a bit too vocal about it. I’m not browsing Lemmy for political content most of the time, yet it seems like some hexbear people feel the need to turn everything into a political discussion. That kinda content is fine in some places, but less welcome in others. In my personal life I interact with people all across the political spectum, and with most people I can totally have a normal chat. That works because we bond over shared intrests. It’s very annoying when people constantly try to start discussions, whether I agree with them or not. There’s a time and place for everything.
I don’t think it’s the majority of hexbear, I see plenty of good content from them. But there does appear to be a (relatively to all of Lemmy) quite large group of aggressively political people in there, to the point of trying to spread their ideology everywhere.
I would never deny that the Hexbear people have been overly aggressive and operating on a hair trigger, but it’s not like they are coming into a thread on Right to Repair and saying “let me tell you about the Korean War!” They are nearly-always responding to topics that other people bring up.
Pretty good. It’s my default morning scroll, at least.
I’ve got a lot more comfortable with it since using Alexandrite on desktop and Sync on mobile.
The only thing really missing at the moment is content. It tends to be good for the high profile stuff, but a bit lacking for the niche stuff. I still sneak back to the other place on occasion to catch up on smaller communities… hopefully that will come with time.
I’m interacting with it far more and in far more varied contexts than I had been on reddit for several years. Overall, there isn’t as much useful or entertaining activity in total of course, but the signal to noise ratio is soooooo much higher.
A bit annoyed about defederations and community blocks. If an instance wants to be an island by itself, fine, but you shouldn’t have to stay up to date with random announcements from each instance to figure out all the places you need to have an account to access all the content you want to.
explicit freeze-peach a la exploding heads (the so-called “alt fedi” over on mastodon)
reddit-style free-for-all with just enough moderation to not be voat 2 (the current default of the threadiverse)
strictly moderated "traditional fediverse with proper groups"
porn
of course there will be parts that overlap, but i absolutely expect a split to occur between the “reddit migratees” and “people who want a mastodon with threading” groups, if the second half hasn’t given up on the threadiverse and returned to mastodon already
It’s fun to start with a small user base. The downtime is rough, and I have some minor issues with it like the fact that deleting a comment hides all of the replies to that comment. Overal, though, it’s kew.
I’m loving it. I’m following a lot (about 500 communities) so I’m always seeing new content. It did take a while to find everything I wanted to see though.
I comment and post more than on Reddit partially because it feels more personal, partially because I want the platform to grow
The two problems I have that I can think of right now are there aren’t as many communities/they’re smaller/fractured across instances, and the classic internet hivemind dogpile on topics and stances
Honestly? I’m wondering where all the quality Reddit posters ended up. Some Lemmy comments are even worse than the ones on Reddit, although the lack of gag posts is refreshing.
Browsing through the global feed scratches the same itch as browsing through r/all mindlessly does and I don’t miss much from Reddit, but I really miss r/noncredibledefense, and neither Lemmy spin off community is nearly as active
The only thing I miss from reddit is the ability to use lemmy as a supplement to stack overflow. I still use teddit to occasionally find old posts on places like r/learnprogramming
I’m a junior web dev so I still benefit from old posts that answer basic questions, but I do wish I could just do a ddg lite search and be able to type in ‘lemmy’ and get the answer to my question.
Otherwise there’s just certain subreddits I wish there was a corresponding community here on Lemmy like specific Indie Video Games. These are small issues and I hope Lemmy popularity grows. Not just for my personal wants, but just cuz I like decentralized alternatives as their simply more authentic imho.
Add comment