Now that a lot of the commotion has subsided I’m just curious to know how y’all are finding the Lemmy experience in general and whether you use it regularly like you did reddit?
I enjoy it so far. But I wish more stuff was tagged as NSFW and filtered out. Often I get girls in bikinis in my feed and I don’t want to know about that. I’ve been banning endless communities from my feed but it seems new ones pop up daily.
All in all Ok. There still some toxicity, not enough types of people to dilute some of the fringe or hardcore groups at times. Things like circlejerks seem to have more power outside of their own realm at times, anecdotally at least. Having to swap instances because DDoS or federation policy or the like and then having to reblock the same furry or anime or trans or random niche comic porn sites is a bit tiresome too. I get that the makeup of the users skews towards these groups and their supporters more, it’s just taking more curation I guess.edit: and duplicate posts from multiple instances. Another thing I imagine will be resolved in future.
Those negatives aside it’s been an interesting experience. I feel that I’m getting a broader sense of what’s going on, things that would have been drowned out before now appear to get at least a decent chance if not equal billing in my feed. The new forums have been really good, a very wide range of topics and articles from all around and some properly interesting discussions going on.
It definitely feels more like the earlier internet days at times which can be good as well as bad. I’m looking forward to seeing how it develops
I still prefer it to Reddit. I think there was a noticeable increase in activity after Sync was released - unfortunately since then I have noticed more argumentative / defensive interactions. I guess that just goes with the territory though as more people join and become active, I wish people would just chill though. I feel like I’m having to deal with more children, but it’s still nowhere near as bad as Reddit was.
I’m still missing the diversity of Reddit as I liked lurking in (and learning from) communities I would never come across in the real world, but I hope I will stumble across them in time as I’m sure they’re out there.
It’s good and bad. I miss most of the niche communities that I frequented on Reddit but on the other side I am commenting and interacting on Lemmy much more than reddit. It feels good to have some discussion. Hopefully the niche communities I miss will grow in time. Another good thing is that since Lemmy is much smaller than Reddit I’ll run out of new content quickly and go do something else instead. So now I’m not mindlessly scrolling for ages. I am noticing that since this is such a small community with a very specific group of people that use it (left leaning/tech) that it generally has much less diverse content and memes compared to Reddit. This matters more on Lemmy since most of the content is focused on broad appealing things compared to Reddit which had bigger niche communities.
Just to let you know, your ipv6 address for lemmy.catasaur.xyz is misconfigured, pointing to a local address (fe80). I couldn’t send you a dm, maybe because your ipv6 addr is misconfigured, so replying to a random comment.
I too have recently quit reddit. It was getting hard enough to put up with even without seeing the ads.
Signing up for some instances can be annoying, when a few want you to type out a cover letter of why you want to join them. I get trying to weed out bots but god is it tedious.
You don’t need to sign up to multiple instances, unless those instances are defederated from the instance of your account. I’m not sure why this would be a problem more than once (and at most once).
Example: I follow communities from a bunch of different instances with this single account.
I think it still needs to grow and get more stable. I find any browsing all that there isn’t enough there for me to use it in the same way I used reddit.
For the first month or so, I would say it was about 40% of my SNS usage, now it’s probably about 20-30%. Hopefully as more and more people use it, we get more users and more stable instances.
My opinion is probably in line with most; that for general “news” it’s just fine. For niche topics, most aren’t here or at least aren’t as robust as Reddit
There are two relatively minor features that I do wish would be implemented:
homepage defaults to Subscribed instead of all, or at least a way to set that as the default
a quick jump to top of page button that stays present when you’ve scrolled way down the page. Not sure if that was a RIF addition or native to Reddit, but that was a nice quality of life feature
It’s literally just reddit for me at this point, i use mlmym.org which gives me the old reddit interface so i barely notice even the slightest difference.
If people didn’t make so many posts about drama in the fediverse i would have had no clue there were any problems.
Browsing Lemmy’s front page has replaced reddit’s r/all for me, usually checking top of 12 hours from all instances.
But I still use reddit for specific forums of certain things, because it’s just the biggest community for the particular subject. I usually try to check if I can find the particular subject from Lemmy and check that out first though.
I’m more of a commenter/lurker and I quite rarely make new posts, but when I do make one:
If it’s a question about something I need help with, I’ll start with a Lemmy post and then possibly also make one on Reddit - more readers, more answers.
If it’s just a shitpost/meme/“content”, I only post it on Lemmy.
I stopped using Reddit for anything but getting recipes (the food communities on Lemmy are tiny and inactive, especially for recipes, especially for a subsection like keto recipes), but there is generally not that much content on Lemmy, unless something is rage bait, there is usually very little discussion.
Quality of discourse is also not improved, people still get angry and insult you.
Overall it’s not too bad, and I appreciate the control I have with my own instance, but the world is just smaller & sadder than it was before reddit decided to tell users to fuck off.
Going better than I expected, especially now that we have so many capable clients like Sync. I don’t miss Reddit at all, and I really like that there aren’t any annoying posters like Schnoodle and his circlejerking fanbois, or the LTT fanclub in subs like r/pcmr who’d downvote anyone who criticizes LTT, or Windows fanbois who’d always downvote anything Linux related (I also like that there’s a larger representation of Linux and OSS folks here which is awesome).
I spend like an hour here daily and I’m looking forward to see how much it grows.
Add comment