It’s not fair to say that something is a bad idea and not even say why. Could you please elaborate on why this is a bad idea? It is specifically toggleable -optional whatever. I think it’s a solid idea.
Actually, that’s a really good analogy, and it helped me think about this in a different way.
What if the monkey is the camera in this situation, and the training the monkey part is like designing the sensor on the camera. You can copyright the sensor design(AI Model), and the photo taken using the sensor (output), so the same should apply to AI art, shouldn’t it?
When you take a photo, you have a direct hand in making it - when you direct an AI to make art, it is the one making the art, you just choose what it makes.
I understand what you mean, but you’re still directing the Camera; you’re placing it, adjusting the shot, perfecting lighting etc. Isn’t AI art the same? You have a direct hand in making what you want; through prompting, controlnet, Loras and whatever new thing comes along.
I get where you’re coming from about human involvement in AI art. But consider this: the artist isn’t just dropping a prompt and walking away. They’re often curating the dataset, fine-tuning the model, and making tons of decisions that influence the final piece. It’s kind of like a movie director who shapes every scene even if they’re not on camera.
Also, AI art usually isn’t a one-shot deal. Artists go through multiple iterations, making tweaks and changes to get to the final result. Think of it as sculpting, chipping away until it feels right. It takes hundreds if not thousands of different tries with prompts.
And don’t underestimate the prompt. A well-crafted prompt can guide the AI in ways that make the end product unique and meaningful. So while the AI is a tool, the human is still very much the artist here.
I disagree on the notion that a person that prompted the AI didn’t „make“ the picture. This is the same argument as with digital art, you aren‘t making it, you are simply moving your pen on a screen to create lines and fillings to impress an image. (Also, when it was becoming popular a lot of artists complained that is wasn’t „real art“). To be fair, what someone thinks is art is quite subjective (many people scoff at these random blocks standing around in cities like statues) so it’ll ultimately be up to the lawmakers (that mark my word will lobby to eternity for this to exist) to decide. I respect your opinion, but don’t agree with it. It’s not like you or I can’t enjoy something just because someone else doesn’t.
I disagree on the notion that a person that prompted the AI didn’t „make“ the picture. This is the same argument as with digital art, you aren‘t making it, you are simply moving your pen on a screen to create lines and fillings to impress an image. (Also, when it was becoming popular a lot of artists complained that is wasn’t „real art“). To be fair, what someone thinks is art is quite subjective (many people scoff at these random blocks standing around in cities like statues) so it’ll ultimately be up to the lawmakers (that mark my word will lobby to eternity for this to exist) to decide. I respect your opinion, but don’t agree with it. It’s not like you or I can’t enjoy something just because someone else doesn’t.
It’s better, but I still often see posts with massive amounts of downvotes for no reason.
Also this is specific to SJW, but I often see the opinions from the people that are less invested in the topic being pushed all the way to the bottom, due to the more active people downvoting everything. (agora)
Google's DeepMind unit is unveiling today a new method it says can invisibly and permanently label images that have been generated by artificial intelligence.
I’m not sure that’s the case. For instance, a lot of smaller local models leverage GPT4 to generate synthetic training data, which drastically improves the model’s output quality. The issue comes in when there is no QC on the model’s output. The same applies to Stable Diffusion.
ah, I see. I was aware that Madeline was trans, but I didn’t know it was such a widespread meme. one quick search and actually, that explains a lot. like the mirror temple and such
Sorry for dumping my thought process for the last five minutes lol
I like to joke that I can’t be trans because I failed to complete the very first level
what does still struggling halfway on farewell make me ಠ_ಠ
Microsoft Needs So Much Power to Train AI That It's Considering Small Nuclear Reactors (futurism.com)
The same thing we do every night Pinky (startrek.website)
Tech support rule (lemmy.world)
Please i need a waifu wallpaper (lemmy.world)
Guys, i not ask much, just a wallpaper who match with rose pine colors
I heard it's starting to get better (lemdro.id)
the way it is (feddit.de)
Please....I just want to play Armored Core....please don't overheat.... (lemmy.world)
Opinion: The Copyright Office is making a mistake on AI-generated art (arstechnica.com)
Donkey Rule (lemmy.blahaj.zone)
I want to know how queer this place is rule (poll in the body text) (lemmy.blahaj.zone)
I come up with the best ideas only when I’m extremely sleep deprived...
Twitter, Reddit, Unity, Blizzard... who else? (startrek.website)
What about a new mixed-feed which merges the Subscribed, Local and All feed based on probabilities customable by the user e.g. 10/40/50 or 0/20/80? (lemmy.world)
cross-posted from: lemmy.world/post/5157579...
deleted_by_moderator
appreciate it (lemmy.ml)
US rejects AI copyright for famous state fair-winning Midjourney art (arstechnica.com)
Controversial AI art piece from 2022 lacks human authorship required for registration.
Tim Burton Slams AI-Generated Artwork - IGN (www.ign.com)
Legendary filmmaker Tim Burton has slammed AI-generated artwork, saying it "takes something from your soul or psyche".
You'll never take me alive (startrek.website)
please stay there (feddit.de)
furry rule (files.catbox.moe)
https://www.tumblr.com/music-sync-maniac/727728860950675456
Donald Trule (i.imgur.com)
Never too many rule (lemmy.blahaj.zone)
rule (lemmy.blahaj.zone)
they got travel sized blahaj now
Google debuts a new way to watermark AI-generated images (www.axios.com)
Google's DeepMind unit is unveiling today a new method it says can invisibly and permanently label images that have been generated by artificial intelligence.
Let's play a game, and please play by the rules (lemmy.ml)
Do you hate having your picture taken because...
i have 550 hours on beat saber rule (lemmy.blahaj.zone)
infinity for reddit wont work starting tomorrow so i will shitpost here every day instead :3
Wearing only socks feels more naked than being completely naked
monday left me bruleoken (lemmy.blahaj.zone)
Image Transcription:...
Today's The Rule (youtu.be)
1 Rule Left :( (lemmy.world)
AI-Created Art Isn’t Copyrightable, Judge Says In Ruling That Could Give Hollywood Studios Pause (www.hollywoodreporter.com)