Weird professional norms question re social science #PeerReview
A great reviewer objected to a measure I used by giving a long summary of problems with historical newspapers as sources in the era I discuss. The reviewer is correct, & as a result, I'm moving that set of results to an appendix & contextualizing them with a summary of the issues
The reviewer didn't point me to sources & I've only found them for some of the specific points. I can't just quote the review, can I?!
