ColesStreetPothole, to allstartrek
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar

I had a lot of thoughts about this episode after it ended. In no particular order:

  1. It was reminiscent of TNG episode The Neutral Zone, which had humans in stasis chambers because they had "incurable" diseases.

  2. The whole point was to get Janeway and Earhart to meet and talk. The rest was sort of cobbled together to justify that happening.

@allstartrek

ColesStreetPothole,
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar

@allstartrek
3. There were a LOT of incongruities or paper-thin plot elements that required the viewer to just suspend disbelief and go along for the ride. WHICH IS FINE. We all know that truck wouldn't start. (Did they ever explain how it got there? Did the Briori just yeet it because it was smelly? If so, why not in the Alpha Quadrant?)

  1. The "use them as slaves" thing didn't make sense. Was something cut fro the show?
    @allstartrek
ColesStreetPothole,
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar
  1. They must have exhausted their budget on the stasis chamber set! 😂 Because they had no money left over for a location shoot visiting one of the cities. I would have loved to have seen a parallel-developed human civilization, and how it tugged at crewmembers' hearts. But no, all we got were a few folks in neoprene suits with pulse rifles. Biggest missed opportunity of the episode (or maybe even the season).

@allstartrek

ColesStreetPothole,
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar

To sum things up, despite the flaws, I really enjoyed this episode. It took a risk and created what is, when you get down to it, a very improbable situation—but it really feeds the "What if....? role that good SF always should. And part of me thinks that if they made this a two-parter and really explored that pang of indecision of whether to leave the planet or stay, it could have been really, really good.
@allstartrek

kcarr2015,
@kcarr2015@mstdn.social avatar

@ColesStreetPothole @allstartrek
Did ever revisit that human colony in the Delta Quadrant?

I can just imagine a attack, and in the aftermath the survivors travel in a ragtag convoy of spaceships, searching for the mythical planet of their origin... Earth!

ColesStreetPothole, to allstartrek
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar

Arizona is like 800 miles from the Gulf of Mexico. Why didn't he say Gulf of California, which is much closer?

@allstartrek

ColesStreetPothole, to allstartrek
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar

Sooooo, we are to believe that a race of aliens that could travel from the Alpha Quadrant to the Delta Quadrant would . . . kidnap humanoids to use as slaves?

@allstartrek

kcarr2015,
@kcarr2015@mstdn.social avatar

@ColesStreetPothole @allstartrek
Every alien race out there knows that humans make terrible slaves. These aliens were obviously idiots!

ColesStreetPothole, to allstartrek
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar

Amelia and Fred are acting like they're on some 1960s sitcom.

@allstartrek

ColesStreetPothole, to allstartrek
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar

So, they've been standing up for 400 years, and they get zapped with something and all of a sudden they can just....walk on out? I mean, my legs get stiff if I stand still for like 20 minutes.

@allstartrek

bmerer, to allstartrek
@bmerer@c.im avatar
ColesStreetPothole, to allstartrek
@ColesStreetPothole@weatherishappening.network avatar
  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • uselessserver093
  • Food
  • aaaaaaacccccccce
  • test
  • CafeMeta
  • testmag
  • MUD
  • RhythmGameZone
  • RSS
  • dabs
  • KamenRider
  • TheResearchGuardian
  • KbinCafe
  • Socialism
  • oklahoma
  • SuperSentai
  • feritale
  • All magazines