Canvas -- Lemmy's r/Place -- Happening this weekend!

dingus , 11 months ago

Cool, but I would argue that we should be creating our own traditions, not copying… *checks notes …a sad ploy to increase MAU numbers.

I mean, back in the day, the games we used to play on forums were stuff like “Google Images Word Association” where someone would produce a random image, then someone else uses words that image made them think of, then search images based on that, then add another image to the thread, based on their word-search. Resulted in a lot of dumb funny shit.

Anyway… Great idea, but it pains me that it’s just copying some bullshit from reddit that wasn’t about community but rather a weak attempt to gin up engagement metrics.

beta_tester , 11 months ago

It sounds more like someone thinks reddit’s r/place is cool but doesn’t want to support reddit and wants to have it for lemmy. And most importantly, the person brings it to lemmy.

Although it’s just a copy, it’s something fun where you can create something cool. And I celebrate OP for creating this. Count me in.

dingus , 11 months ago

Not trying to be down on anyone’s good time, I hope folks have fun with it. It’s just my personal opinion on the matter, that it’s better to create our own culture than grandfather in “culture” that wasn’t actually culture but corporate nonsense masquerading as “culture.”

Put it up there with all the people that complain that using Lemmy is “too hard” because it’s not enough like Reddit. It’s a bunch of “well corporations did this, why can’t you?” type feeling. I just don’t like that feeling, I’d rather have a community actually grow organically without corporate influence.

To quote Boo Boo Bear:

corporations rob us of our dignity and independence

When we rely on them for everything, even our definitions of what “culture” is, we have lost.

beta_tester , 11 months ago

I get your point.

I’m happy enough that lemmy is currently at a point where there’s enough content for every days business. Let’s see where it goes. Everyone can create such little fun games. Now you don’t have to wait for reddit anymore.

Richie030 , 11 months ago

This will end up with a giant fuck spez too won’t it, not sure the timing is right, I hope I’m wrong

callyral , 11 months ago

How does this work? Like which webpage would people place the pixels? Would it work with Kbin too?

Demigodrick , 11 months ago

There is a dedicated site which will be announced on the date - creator is adding a way for kbin users to authenticate and join in.

someguy3 , 11 months ago

At least say c/place.

This feels very forced. Could have waited awhile.

Not even sure there’s enough users. Do we really want the bad image of a failed c/place?

morrowind , 11 months ago

I think they’re trying to call it “Canvas”

someguy3 , 11 months ago

Heh I missed that completely when I saw place.

greendakota99 , 11 months ago

c/anvas

palitu , 11 months ago

That seems like a missed opportunity

theodewere , 11 months ago

it's a cheap trick they use to make people more territorial and easier to market to.. it's not really relevant here..

NaibofTabr , 11 months ago

We need to get our own traditions

why not start off with our own r/Place

…

If the plan was to provide evidence for the idea that Lemmy is a second-rate, tryhard copycat, well done!

This community is perfectly capable of generating its own traditions without trying to force it… and the fact that reddit recently tried to use r/Place to distract from the recent controversy makes this imitation that much sadder. If you’re going to crib something, at least go for something that hasn’t been touched for awhile.

morrowind , 11 months ago

beans is one of the most ubiquitous memes on the internet. It’s not “ours” any more than r/place is.

XPost3000 , 11 months ago

Yeah the 3 day no poop guy is so far the only large Lemmy specific meme I’ve seen so far

Atrabiliousaurus , 11 months ago

Any bot mitigation or account age requirements planned?

maegul , 11 months ago

Plenty of comments here critical of whether we want this here etc … all I’ll say is it’s fucking awesome that you went ahead and made something on the fediverse!! Good for you … I hope you have fun and it goes well!!!